SS Central America: The Story of the Sunken Ship of Gold
Gold from the California gold rush became part of one of the most dramatic stories ever told – the sinking of a ship known as the “Ship of Gold”. Its treasure lay on the floor of the Atlantic for more than 130 years, and its rediscovery ended in a lawsuit, a flight from justice and long years behind bars.
Disaster in a hurricane (1857)
In September 1857 the paddle steamer SS Central America was sailing from the coast of Panama towards New York carrying more than 15 tonnes of gold from the California gold rush. Off the coast of the Carolinas the ship ran into a hurricane and sank on 12 September 1857. Of the 578 people on board, only 153 survived.
An economic shock: the Panic of 1857
At the time of the sinking, the gold on board was worth around 2 million dollars. The loss of this gold, which was meant to bolster the reserves of New York banks, is regarded as one of the greatest economic disasters in American maritime history and contributed to the outbreak of the Panic of 1857, which plunged the US economy into a severe recession.
130 years on the ocean floor
The wreck remained lost for more than 130 years, surrounded by legends of a treasure that had vanished without a trace. Its exact location was unknown all that time.
The 1988 discovery: Tommy Thompson and the robot Nemo
In 1988 the American ocean engineer Tommy Thompson succeeded in locating the wreck of the SS Central America. His team used a specially built remotely operated vehicle called “Nemo” and recovered thousands of coins and hundreds of gold bars from the depths.
A dispute with investors and a flight from justice
Investors had funded the expedition with around 12.7 million dollars. The recovered gold was later sold for around 50 million dollars – but according to a 2005 lawsuit, the investors never saw any return. When Thompson was due to appear in court in 2012, he failed to show up and went into hiding for about two years.
Years in custody for his silence
In 2015 Thompson was caught in Florida, where he had been living under a false identity. He then spent around a decade in custody – not only for defrauding investors but above all for contempt of court, because he refused to reveal the whereabouts of 500 gold coins worth around 2.5 million dollars. Where those coins are remains publicly unknown to this day.
What to take away
The story of the SS Central America is an extreme illustration of how complicated and risky owning gold can be when it is not in your own hands – whether it is treasure on the seabed or an investment entrusted to an unreliable third party. A similar counterparty risk is discussed in the article Risks of gold savings plans.
Frequently asked questions
Was the SS Central America gold ever returned to the investors?
No, according to available information the investors who financed the expedition received no return from the sale, despite lawsuits against Thompson.
Where are the remaining 500 gold coins today?
Their exact hiding place is not publicly known – Thompson refused to reveal it even after years in custody for contempt of court.
Why is the sinking considered such a significant economic event?
The loss of a large amount of gold meant to strengthen bank reserves in New York deepened the crisis of confidence in the banking sector and contributed to the Panic of 1857, one of the first globally interconnected financial crises.
Related articles
About the author
Adolf Baumann, analyst at Baumann Group a.s. (GOLDU), has been working with precious metals for over 30 years. He has seen euphoria, crashes and panic on the markets – and he still enjoys it. He explains in plain language what moves the price of gold and silver and how to handle them without unnecessary mistakes. His weakness? He refuses to wear a suit.
